Showing posts with label corporate evil. Show all posts
Showing posts with label corporate evil. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 3, 2013

Down the road, a furor's brewing


On Tuesday, the Palmer Town Council voted to approve a “host community agreement” with Mohegan Sun for a potential casino off the Mass Pike there. It's a big deal – a $15.2 million initial payment plus about $13.2 million a year plus upgrades to town infrastructure the report claims will benefit residents to varying degrees plus a small percentage of the “gross gaming revenue.”
Sounds great, right? Wish it were here?
Nope. To me, having a casino in any town of Palmer's or Southbridge's size means essentially surrendering the community to all of the downsides of a one-company town with few of the benefits. Unlike major cities, where there's enough other economic activity to keep things moving, small towns can't support an entity that's so disproportionately big.
In theory, it provides jobs and tax money, but the reality is that happens at the expense of strangling the other businesses in town. That's twofold: because the casino is not locally-owned, almost all of its profits go elsewhere, and it has no reason to promote other businesses in town. It's essentially a self-contained $1 billion mini-city, with multiple retail stores, restaurants, a hotel, theater and even a water park as part of the plans. 
The whole point of a casino is to trap you inside until you run out of money, and this one will have its own Pike exit to eliminate even the need to drive by those local businesses en route. You don't visit what you never see.
Palmer's agreement refers to something called a “Players' Club Card Program” by which casino patrons get “redemption opportunities” at local non-casino businesses – whatever that means. Can they redeem the mortgage payments and kids' college funds they just squandered? I doubt it. If more than a handful of people actually use it and local businesses get anything from it, I'd be very surprised. It smells of pure propaganda, with the casino knowing it'll pay out next to nothing, but then be able to blame the players.
At their best, the historic mill towns were the polar opposite. Although one company often dominated and some were abusive, the owners typically actually lived in town, frequented the other businesses, participated in town affairs, and otherwise had a vested interest in ensuring the community thrived. As in Southbridge, they're often buried in the towns they had a hand in building, even though they also got far richer than the average person.
Those towns, in fact, typically “went south” when the company was sold to some outsider, usually a faceless, soulless corporation. In Southbridge, such a sale eventually led to American Optical (AO, or the "hey-ho" to locals) being sold off piecemeal, some parts moving out of state, some simply disintegrating, but all leaving a giant gap that still hasn't been filled in the town's psyche.
With casinos, the soulless corporation starts the process, and things go downhill from there. Sure, there will probably be an initial rush of cash and some noticeable town projects getting done that have been needed for years. $15 million is a huge chunk of most town's budgets -- In Palmer, it's HALF of what the town spends in a year, and nearly equals its annual tax collection.
I can hear some people cheering, since that would theoretically all but eliminate everyone else's taxes or the town's need for state aid. Maybe, but at what cost? History is laden with examples of huge financial windfalls corrupting communities and/or resulting in the “benefactor” eventually taking off the smiling face and effectively taking over the town for its own benefit. Giant sums of money are extremely hazardous to healthy democracies and tend to undermine the more general sense of community, especially when they're in the hands of one person or company, and doubly so when that firm's profits go elsewhere.
People in Southbridge still cast a wary eye on Casella because of the fiscal impact from the annual landfill royalties (among other things), and that sum is FAR less than Mohegan Sun's would be. While I imagine few Palmerites will even see this column, I hope they consider these points and reject the host agreement – and the casino itself – when their chance to vote comes.

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Welcome ... diving right in

Hi, All,
Since I don't much like talking about myself, I'll keep this brief. If you know me, you might recognize some of these columns as ones I wrote for Southbridge Evening News in Massachusetts*; I'll splice those  in occasionally among new things exploring energy, ecology, local and world politics, science & scifi, nuclear weapons & power, history, maps, and pretty much anything else that comes to mind... If you don't, I'm a farmer, journalist, locally-active citizen, unabashedly Green and communitarian, somewhat luddite, anarchist and what I'd call an "optimistic realist" -- I know we CAN solve the problems we face (and there are many), but I'm not sure we WILL.
We'll get into all that in due time. for now I'll dive right in ...
(*In this post's case, I'm writing it here first, but it'll appear in the SEN this Friday.)
Gus


Blackout, 10 years after

Over the last few days, NPR and various other media have been revisiting the great blackout of August 2003, where around 50 million people across the Northeast and parts of Canada lost power. Some lost it just for a few hours, some for several days, although New England itself was largely spared.
As might be expected from the mainstream outlets, there's a fair amount of talk from the people who run the current system about the changes they've made to avoid a similar system crash going forward. To them, that means spending millions, even billions, to implement the "smart grid," based largely on electronic metering that sends household energy use data to the utilities every hour or so and more electronics that measure the flows within the system itself. On the government side, the blackout prompted a push to give the regional transmission organizations (non-profit corporations overseeing the grid; ours is ISO-New England) greater authority.
Sounds great, right?
Sounds unnecessarily complicated to me.
Leaving aside the claims of health effects from the meters (which I'm not convinced about) and potential privacy concerns (which could be a problem), this approach only makes the underlying problem WORSE, not better. Yes, it puts more eyes in place to watch and prevent problems. But it still strengthens the centralization of the energy system, and therefore its overall vulnerability, when the real need is to promote a huge increase in distributed generation and storage, with local ownership by communities or private coops, and the like. 
To some degree, there has been investment there, too -- but not enough. That's largely due to strong opposition from the established utilities, fossil fuel firms and their campaign contributions in Congress and at other levels. Here in Mass., there has been a bill languishing in the Legislature for some time that would make it easier for towns to create their own power companies, and that would help if passed (if it's funded). 
Unfortunately, there's also one (S. 1600) that seems, based on my reading, to give existing private utilities monopolies in the name of "competition." It states firms serving areas on Jan. 1, 2013, will have "exclusive obligation to provide distribution service to all retail customers within its service territory, and no other person shall provide distribution service within such service territory without the written consent of such distribution company." It calls for a competitive bidding process to procure power source "not less than every 15 years" but specifically excludes any company or subsidiary that's "regulated by the department," saying those firms cannot "be allowed to use the distribution system of another electric company" without a state "restructuring plan." Later, that bill seems to exempt municipal light plants from having to be part of this arrangement.
None of this goes in the right direction. As we saw in 2007-8, the "too big to fail" mentality -- which is as rampant in the energy sector as in banking -- is a guarantee of big trouble, and should be treated as "too big to be allowed to live." For our own long-term well-being, we need to get away from "big energy" and re-learn how to tap the local energy supplies using companies that are democratically owned. 
True energy independence will greatly vary from place to place, and won't look at all like what the giant oil firms blather regarding making us "Saudi America." While some areas DO have good supplies of oil and gas to support themselves, the worldwide use of them is screwing up our climate. By contrast, almost anywhere can make solar work well -- Germany gets around 20 percent of its power from solar despite having less sunlight than even New England does -- but the panels themselves require rare earths and other materials with a significant energy cost to mine and construct. If they last, logic says they'll make up the difference over time, although I can't claim to know how long that takes. 
For that reason and others (local geography, for one), it might be better to invest instead in wind (if you're in Wyoming, say), tidal power (Nova Scotia and many seacoasts), or small hydro. As history shows, the latter is ideal for New England with our numerous small rivers, and with modern technology, we can use smaller, more efficient turbines that don't require the dams and river disruption the old mills had. A big plus is that it's nearly impossible to centralize -- the hydro network we have encourages local ownership. 
What gets in the way today is a complex state and federal approval process that costs millions, putting it out of reach of the people who most need new power sources. Such facilities should be sited carefully to protect the rivers and serve the community well, but I suspect the process is cumbersome specifically because it discourages independence from the big energy firms. "Energy independence" has never been about independence for you and me or the US as a nation, but about ExxonMobil, National Grid and similar giants being rich enough to ignore our real needs.
It's time we declared our independence of such manipulation and the risk of future energy crashes it all but guarantees.